Polyurethane vs Epoxy Table Top: What Are the Pros and Cons?

Thinking about giving your table a fresh new look but not sure which finish to use? The choice between a polyurethane vs epoxy table top mostly comes down to style, strength, and how easy it is to work with. At Lumber Grand, we’ll break it all down so you can pick the one that fits your vibe and your weekend DIY plans.

What Are Polyurethane vs Epoxy Table Top Finishes?

If you're looking to protect or refresh your table top, you’ve probably seen the names polyurethane vs epoxy table top pop up. Both of them are popular ways to seal and protect table tops, but they work differently and give very different results.

Epoxy Finish: Epoxy is a 2-part liquid (resin + hardener) that hardens into a thick, glossy surface. Once it cures, it creates a tough, clear coat that feels almost like glass.
Polyurethane Finish: Polyurethane is a plastic based coating that comes in oil based or water based formulas. It’s often used on wood furniture to protect from wear and moisture.

Now that you know what each finish is all about, let’s dive into how they really compare!

polyurethane vs epoxy for table top

A quick look at the key differences between polyurethane vs epoxy table top
Photo: ©MarieTDebs On Canva.com; WOOD Magazine

Polyurethane vs Epoxy Table Top: Pros, Cons, and Key Features

Both polyurethane vs epoxy table top offer great protection for your table top options, but they bring unique qualities to the table. Below is a comparison of key features between these two finishes, focusing on their pros and cons to help you decide which one is the best fit for your project.

Feature	Polyurethane Finish	Epoxy Finish
Durability Scratch Resistance	Good durability and flexibility. Resistant to scratches and impacts. Ideal for surfaces with constant movement.	Extremely strong and rigid. Ideal for heavy duty uses (like industrial coatings). Can be brittle under impact.
Aesthetic Finish	Available in various sheens (matte to high gloss). Offers more options to highlight the natural beauty of wood.	Provides a high gloss, glass like finish. Enhances depth and clarity. Great for artistic projects.
Application Process	Comes in ready to use, single-component formulas. Easier to apply. Cures faster, user friendly for DIYers.	Requires careful mixing and precise measurement of resin and hardener. Longer curing time.
Cost Comparison	Higher initial cost. More cost effective over time due to its long lasting durability.	Lower initial cost. May require more frequent touch ups or refinishing depending on usage.
Workability Maintenance	Easier to apply and repair. Can be spot repaired without refinishing the entire surface. Better UV resistance than epoxy. Moderate chemical resistance.	Repairs can be challenging. Damage often requires refinishing the entire surface to maintain uniformity. Highly resistant to chemicals. Can yellow or degrade with UV exposure.

Polyurethane is a flexible and durable finish ideal for projects that need to handle daily wear and tear. It’s especially suited for outdoor furniture, as it offers better UV protection than epoxy, preventing sun damage. Polyurethane also requires less ongoing maintenance, making it a low maintenance option for surfaces exposed to heavy use.

Epoxy is known for its strong, hard surface and glass like finish. It excels at resisting chemicals, making it a great choice for countertops or bar tops. However, epoxy can become brittle and break down with prolonged exposure to UV light, making it less suitable for outdoor use compared to polyurethane.

Now, let's move on to the next section about when to choose epoxy vs polyurethane for table top. Each finish works best for specific needs, and Lumber Grand will help you figure out which one is right for your project!

epoxy vs polyurethane table top

Choosing the right finish for your project: polyurethane vs epoxy table top?
Photo: ©BanksPhotos; Thaicha on Canva.com

When to Use Epoxy vs. Polyurethane for Table Tops?

Choosing between polyurethane vs epoxy table top really comes down to what your project needs. Here's when each finish works best:

1. Ideal Uses for Polyurethane Finish

Polyurethane is a great choice for many different projects. Here are a few situations where this finish works best:

High Traffic Areas: Polyurethane is a great choice for surfaces like dining tables or kitchens, hallways, stairs and desks that get a lot of use. Whether you're eating, working, or doing crafts, this finish keeps your furniture looking good longer.

Wood Preservation: If you want to bring out the natural beauty of your wood, polyurethane is the way to go. It enhances the wood grain and color without hiding any of its natural texture. Plus, it adds a layer of protection to help keep it safe from damage.
Quick Drying Projects: In a rush? Water based polyurethane is your best friend. It dries much faster than oil based polyurethane, so you can finish your project in no time.

epoxy resin vs polyurethane table top

Gloss polyurethane preserves wood with a durable and flexible finish
Photo: ©BanksPhotos on Canva.com

2. Ideal Uses for Epoxy Finish

Epoxy is also a great choice for a range of projects, especially when you want a glossy finish. Here are some of the best table top epoxy:

Glossy, High Gloss Surfaces: Epoxy is perfect if you're looking for a thick, shiny, glass like finish for your table tops or countertops. If you want your table to have that polished, glossy finish that catches the light, epoxy is a top choice.
Artistic Projects: Epoxy can actually enhance objects, which makes it perfect for things like river tables or adding custom designs. Whether you’re embedding colorful stones, shells, or even personal items, epoxy lets you create unique pieces. And, on top of looking stunning, they’re durable enough to last for years.
Food Safety Considerations: If your epoxy project will be used in a place where food is involved, like a kitchen or dining table, it’s important to choose a food safe epoxy. This ensures the surface is safe for food contact, so you can enjoy your work with peace of mind.

ideal uses for epoxy finish

Epoxy delivers a glossy, high gloss surface perfect for artistic and high impact projects
Photo: Lumber Grand
Shop now: Round Black Epoxy River Table Top 23 Inches; Round Wood Epoxy Dining Table Top 35 Inches

Still unsure which finish to choose? Check out the epoxy table top collection and contact us at +1(213) 834-1213 to find the perfect match for your table!

Both polyurethane vs epoxy table top have their own strengths and weaknesses. With the right information from Lumber Grand, you can pick the one that fits your table top project best. Whether you're fixing up a family heirloom or working on a new DIY creation, the right finish will protect and bring out the best in your project.

Rating

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ (10)